Butterscotch

A warm, light orange brown named after a butter and sugar sweet from Doncaster in Yorkshire.

Overview

Butterscotch is a warm, light orange brown. Its usual code, #E09540, has red at 88%, green at 58% and blue at 25%, a glowing amber that sits between orange and brown. Next to caramel it looks lighter and more orange; next to fawn, stronger and less pink.

The name comes from a Yorkshire sweet of butter, sugar and treacle, tied to Doncaster from its first records. A newspaper printed a recipe for “Doncaster butterscotch” in 1848, and by 1851 several rival Doncaster confectioners were selling it. Where the “scotch” comes from is still argued over. It probably has nothing to do with Scotland: the main theories are an old verb meaning to score or cut, and the word scorch.

As a color, butterscotch has drifted. Maerz and Paul’s A Dictionary of Color (1930) had a butterscotch sample that the 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary files as moderate brown and moderate yellowish brown, a mid brown close to toffee, and Merriam-Webster still defines the color as a moderate yellowish brown. Later sources went lighter: a 1950 dictionary put butterscotch among orange yellows, and people in the xkcd color survey picked a bright golden orange, #FDB147. The code sits between the two, much nearer the modern view.

Butterscotch is a light, warm mid-tone. Black or very dark brown text reads well on it, at 8.5 to 1; white text doesn’t, at under 2.5 to 1. It looks old-fashioned and sweet with cream, rich with chocolate and deep red, and bright against navy or plum.

HEX#E09540
RGBrgb(224, 149, 64)
HSLhsl(32, 72%, 56%)
HSV32°, 71%, 88%
CMYK0, 33, 71, 12
OKLCHoklch(73.0% 0.134 66.0)
Every code converts from the HEX value #E09540. #E09540 is the butterscotch most color lists use. Wikipedia’s “Shades of orange” gives it, crediting a commercial textile color system rather than a public standard, and places it in the ISCC-NBS strong orange group. No open standard defines it. The ISCC-NBS dictionary (1955) files Maerz and Paul’s 1930 butterscotch in two much darker browns; see the range below. CMYK is a screen-based estimate; print results vary.
Butterscotch color card, hex #E09540: “Butter late than never”

Butterscotch on the color map

People’s average butterscotch in the xkcd survey sits near the top of the outline, a little to the right: lighter and yellower. The 1950 dictionary’s moderate orange yellow is just above the reference, inside the outline. Its strong yellowish brown and both groups for Maerz and Paul’s butterscotch are far darker and sit well below the outline; moderate brown, the darkest, is also to the left, redder. The outline is an approximate range, not a measured one.

Shades and tints

Tints with white

Shades with black

Tones with gray

Butterscotch sits in the middle. Tints add white, shades add black and tones add gray, in 10% steps out from it. Tap any swatch to copy its code.

Light and dark butterscotch

#F3D5B3
Pale butterscotchMixed 60% with white. A soft, creamy peach for backgrounds.
#FDB147
Survey butterscotchThe xkcd survey average: what people called butterscotch. Brighter and yellower.
#E09540
ButterscotchThe reference color.
#E3A857
Orange yellow butterscotchThe ISCC-NBS moderate orange yellow, one of three groups for butterscotch in the 1950 Taylor, Knoche and Granville dictionary. See indian yellow
#865926
Deep butterscotchMixed 40% with black. Dark enough for white text, for buttons and headings.
#826644
Dictionary butterscotchThe ISCC-NBS moderate yellowish brown, one of two groups where the 1955 dictionary files Maerz and Paul’s 1930 butterscotch.
#6F4E37
CoffeeThe ISCC-NBS moderate brown, the other group for Maerz and Paul’s butterscotch, and the code for coffee. See coffee

Colors that go with butterscotch

Pairings that work in rooms, outfits and interfaces.

Butterscotch pudding

Butterscotch with cream and a dark brown, like a pudding cup. Sweet and homey, for bakeries and menus.

Victorian sweet tin

Deep red, gold and near-black, like an old tin of boiled sweets. Rich and festive.

Butterscotch and navy

Warm against cool. Crisp for branding and fall clothing.

Seventies kitchen

Butterscotch with avocado green and brown, a retro look for posters and cafés.

Butterscotch and plum

Orange brown against a deep purple. Warm and grown-up, for packaging and invitations.

Butterscotch and slate

A warm accent on cool gray. Calm and modern, good for interfaces.

Color-wheel palettes

Pick a palette to see where its colors sit on the color wheel. The caret marks butterscotch. Tap a band to copy its code.

Similar colors

Tangerine78%Peru73%ButterscotchIndian yellow77%Gamboge84%Marigold78%Goldenrod75%

Lined up by hue around butterscotch. Hover a color to see how similar it is.The bar under each name shows how similar it is. Similarity comes from the distance between the two colors in OKLab, a model of how we see color.

Butterscotch vs caramel

Butterscotch#E09540 · hue 32°
  • Lighter and more orange
  • Named after a Yorkshire sweet
  • Was a mid brown in 1930
Caramel#C68E17 · hue 41°
  • Darker and more golden
  • Named after browned sugar
  • Sits between gold and brown

Meaning

  • Yorkshire sweet
  • Doncaster
  • Disputed name
  • Royal sweetmeat

Butterscotch brings to mind old-fashioned sweets, puddings and warm golden browns. Its meanings come from a Doncaster sweet and a name nobody has fully explained. Color research tests broad words like brown and orange, not butterscotch, so the claims here are about the sweet, its name and how dictionaries place the color.

A Doncaster sweet from the start

Historical record

The earliest records tie butterscotch to Doncaster in Yorkshire. In 1848 the Liverpool Mercury printed a recipe for “Doncaster butterscotch”: a pound of butter, a pound of sugar and a quarter pound of treacle, boiled together. By 1851 rival Doncaster confectioners were selling it through agents across Yorkshire, and the tins became one of the town’s best-known exports.1

Nobody knows what “scotch” means

Word history

Food historians have several theories and none is settled. One links the word to an old verb, scotch, from Middle English scocchen, to score or cut, since the sweet is marked into pieces before it hardens. Another derives it from scorch. Wiktionary says it is not from Scotland or Scotch whisky. An 1855 Yorkshire glossary spells it “butterscot” and also lists a “sugar-scot”, a sweet made in shallow pans and enriched with butter, which hints that “scot” named a kind of sweet, though the glossary doesn’t say why.1, 2, 3

Sold as royal, and as a cough cure

Advertising and local lore

Local tradition says Queen Victoria was given a tin of Doncaster butterscotch in 1851. Advertisements in the Leeds Mercury in 1853 called it “The Queen’s Sweetmeat” and “the best emollient for the chest in the winter season”. The royal story comes from a local newspaper’s history, not a court record.1

Often a flavor, not the sweet

Dictionary definition

Merriam-Webster defines butterscotch as a candy of brown sugar and butter and also the flavor of such candy. That second sense is how most people meet it now, in butterscotch pudding, sauce and chips, where no actual butterscotch is involved.4, 1

Its shade has never been fixed

Color dictionaries

Color references disagree on butterscotch. The 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary files Maerz and Paul’s 1930 sample as moderate brown and moderate yellowish brown, and Merriam-Webster calls the color a moderate yellowish brown. Taylor, Knoche and Granville’s 1950 dictionary ranges from moderate orange yellow to strong yellowish brown, and the xkcd survey average is a bright golden orange.5, 6, 4, 7

Sources (7)
  1. Wikipedia, “Butterscotch”, sections Etymology and History, citing the Liverpool Mercury (1 February 1848), the Sheffield & Rotherham Independent (December 1851), the Leeds Mercury (29 January 1853), the Doncaster Free Press (2017) and the Washington Post (7 March 2007).
  2. Wiktionary, “butterscotch” and “scotch”, etymology.
  3. Robinson, F. K. (1855). A Glossary of Yorkshire Words and Phrases, Collected in Whitby and the Neighbourhood, entries “Butterscot” and “Sweet-scot”. Internet Archive scan.
  4. Merriam-Webster, “butterscotch”, definitions and first known use.
  5. Jaffer, A. “(M) Dictionary of Color”, the ISCC-NBS placements of Maerz and Paul’s color names (1955 dictionary), MIT CSAIL.
  6. Jaffer, A. “(T) Descriptive Color Names Dictionary”, the ISCC-NBS placements of Taylor, Knoche and Granville’s color names (1950), MIT CSAIL.
  7. Munroe, R. (2010). “Color Survey Results”, with the xkcd color list (CC0).

History

Butterscotch began as a Yorkshire sweet in the 1840s and reached the color dictionaries in the 20th century, where it started out as a mid brown and grew lighter and more orange over time.

  1. 1847

    First known use of the word “butterscotch”, for the candy, according to Merriam-Webster.1

  2. 1848

    The Liverpool Mercury prints a recipe for “Doncaster butterscotch”: a pound of butter, a pound of sugar and a quarter pound of treacle, boiled together.2

  3. 1851

    Rival Doncaster confectioners sell butterscotch commercially through agents across Yorkshire. Local tradition says Queen Victoria was given a tin that year.2

  4. 1853

    Advertisements in the Leeds Mercury sell Doncaster butterscotch as “The Queen’s Sweetmeat” and “the best emollient for the chest in the winter season”.2

  5. 1855

    F. K. Robinson’s Whitby glossary defines “butterscot” as a “treacle ball, with an amalgamation of butter in it, a richer compound than the common sweetball”.3

  6. c. 1900

    In the late 19th and early 20th centuries the British sweet becomes popular in the United States.2

  7. 1930

    Maerz and Paul’s A Dictionary of Color includes butterscotch. In 1955 the ISCC-NBS dictionary files their sample as moderate brown and moderate yellowish brown, centered on #6F4E37 and #826644.4

  8. 1950

    Taylor, Knoche and Granville’s Descriptive Color Names Dictionary lists a much lighter butterscotch, which ISCC-NBS files as moderate orange yellow, dark orange yellow and strong yellowish brown.5

  9. 2010

    In the xkcd color survey, people’s average butterscotch is a bright golden orange, #FDB147, lighter than both the dictionaries and the usual code.6

Sources (6)
  1. Merriam-Webster, “butterscotch”, first known use.
  2. Wikipedia, “Butterscotch”, section History, citing the Liverpool Mercury (1 February 1848), the Sheffield & Rotherham Independent (December 1851), the Leeds Mercury (29 January 1853), the Doncaster Free Press (2017) and Hopkins, K. (2012), Sweet Tooth, p. 170.
  3. Robinson, F. K. (1855). A Glossary of Yorkshire Words and Phrases, Collected in Whitby and the Neighbourhood, entry “Butterscot”. Internet Archive scan.
  4. Jaffer, A. “(M) Dictionary of Color”, the ISCC-NBS placements of Maerz and Paul’s color names (1955 dictionary), MIT CSAIL.
  5. Jaffer, A. “(T) Descriptive Color Names Dictionary”, the ISCC-NBS placements of Taylor, Knoche and Granville’s color names (1950), MIT CSAIL.
  6. Munroe, R. (2010). “Color Survey Results”, with the xkcd color list (CC0).

Questions

What color is butterscotch?

A warm, light orange brown. The code used here is #E09540 (RGB 224, 149, 64).

Where does the name butterscotch come from?

From a butter, sugar and treacle sweet first recorded in Doncaster, Yorkshire, in the 1840s. What “scotch” means is disputed: the main theories are an old verb meaning to score or cut, since the sweet is marked into pieces, and the word scorch.

Is butterscotch from Scotland?

Probably not. Its earliest records are all from Yorkshire in England, and dictionaries that explain the name trace “scotch” to a word for cutting or to scorch, not to Scotland.

What is the difference between butterscotch and caramel?

As colors, butterscotch (#E09540) is lighter and more orange, and caramel (#C68E17) is darker and more golden. Both are warm, light enough for black text.

Is there an official butterscotch color code?

No. #E09540 is the code most color lists use, given by Wikipedia from a commercial textile color system. No open standard defines it, and older dictionaries place butterscotch in darker browns.

Why do some dictionaries call butterscotch brown?

Maerz and Paul’s 1930 butterscotch sample was a mid brown, and the 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary filed it as moderate brown and moderate yellowish brown. Merriam-Webster still defines the color as a moderate yellowish brown. Later sources, and most people today, picture a lighter orange gold.

Does white text work on butterscotch?

Not well. White on #E09540 has a contrast of about 2.5 to 1, below the 4.5 to 1 needed for body text. Black or dark brown text works, at about 8.5 to 1.

What colors go with butterscotch?

Cream and dark brown for a homey look, deep red and near-black for a vintage one, navy or plum for contrast, and avocado green for a retro seventies feel.