Toffee

A warm, medium-dark brown named after sugar and butter boiled until they set hard enough to snap.

Overview

Toffee is a warm, medium-dark brown. Its usual code, #755139, has red at 46%, green at 32% and blue at 22%, a soft reddish brown. It is almost the same color as coffee (#6F4E37): side by side, coffee is only a touch darker.

The name comes from the sweet. English has used the word toffee since 1825, a variant of the older taffy. Toffee is sugar or treacle boiled with butter to the hard-crack stage, 300–310 °F (149–154 °C), when almost no water is left. That is what sets it apart from caramel candy: caramels are made with milk or cream and cooked only to the firm-ball stage, 245–250 °F, so they stay chewy. Toffee sets into a glassy sheet that snaps.

Toffee browns in two ways. Sugar breaks down as it heats, and the milk proteins in butter react with sugars in Maillard browning, the reaction that browns a bread crust. How far it goes depends on the recipe and the cook. A plain milk toffee measured in a 2019 study came out a light golden tan, close to #C58D4F, while treacle toffee, the Bonfire Night kind, is very dark. The code sits toward the dark end of that range.

Toffee is a dependable dark neutral. White text reads well on it, at a contrast of 7 to 1. It looks cozy with cream and caramel gold, festive with apple red, and calm next to teal.

HEX#755139
RGBrgb(117, 81, 57)
HSLhsl(24, 34%, 34%)
HSV24°, 51%, 46%
CMYK0, 31, 51, 54
OKLCHoklch(46.8% 0.061 54.4)
Every code converts from the HEX value #755139. There is no standard toffee. #755139 is the code color lists use; the earliest source found is the open-source color-name-list, which had it in its first release in April 2017 without saying where it came from. Toffee is not in Maerz and Paul’s A Dictionary of Color (1930) or the xkcd survey; the nearest dictionary center is moderate brown, #6F4E37, where the ISCC-NBS dictionary (1955) files Maerz and Paul’s butterscotch. CMYK is a screen-based estimate; print results vary.
Toffee color card, hex #755139: “Oh, snap”

Toffee on the color map

Moderate brown, the ISCC-NBS group for Maerz and Paul’s butterscotch, sits just below the reference inside the outline: a little darker. Their butterscotch’s other group, moderate yellowish brown, sits just inside the outline at the upper right, lighter and yellower. The measured milk toffee and the dictionary’s taffy are far lighter and more golden, above the outline and to the right. The outline is an approximate range, not a measured one.

Shades and tints

Tints with white

Shades with black

Tones with gray

Toffee sits in the middle. Tints add white, shades add black and tones add gray, in 10% steps out from it. Tap any swatch to copy its code.

Light and dark toffee

#C8B9B0
Pale toffeeMixed 60% with white. A warm greige for backgrounds.
#C58D4F
Milk toffeeA plain milk toffee as measured in a 2019 study, converted to sRGB. Much lighter and more golden than the code.
#826644
Dictionary butterscotchThe ISCC-NBS moderate yellowish brown, one of two groups where the 1955 dictionary files Maerz and Paul’s butterscotch.
#755139
ToffeeThe reference color.
#6F4E37
CoffeeThe ISCC-NBS moderate brown, the other group for Maerz and Paul’s butterscotch, and the code for coffee. A touch darker. See coffee
#463122
Dark toffeeMixed 40% with black. A deep brown for text and headings.

Colors that go with toffee

Pairings that work in rooms, outfits and interfaces.

Toffee and cream

Soft and sweet, like a box of wrapped toffees. Good for bakeries and gift labels.

Toffee apple

Glossy brown with apple red and leaf green, like the fall-fair treat.

Bonfire Night

Treacle-dark brown, ember orange and smoke. For November menus and posters.

Toffee and teal

Cool teal against warm brown. Calm and grown-up, for homes and branding.

Toffee and caramel

Two cooked-sugar browns, dark and golden. Rich and warm, like a sweet shop window.

Toffee and blush

Warm brown with a dusty pink. Gentle, for stationery and weddings.

Color-wheel palettes

Pick a palette to see where its colors sit on the color wheel. The caret marks toffee. Tap a band to copy its code.

Similar colors

Wenge78%Mummy brown75%Umber82%Walnut75%Russet81%ToffeeCoffee93%

Lined up by hue around toffee. Hover a color to see how similar it is.The bar under each name shows how similar it is. Similarity comes from the distance between the two colors in OKLab, a model of how we see color.

Toffee vs caramel

Toffee#755139 · hue 24°
  • Darker, redder and grayer
  • Sugar and butter cooked to hard crack
  • Takes white text
Caramel#C68E17 · hue 41°
  • Lighter and more golden
  • Named after browned sugar
  • Needs dark text

Meaning

  • Hard crack
  • Milk browning
  • Bonfire Night
  • The Toffees

Toffee brings to mind sweet shops, Bonfire Night and the snap of a hard sweet. Its meanings come from the candy: how hot it is cooked, why it turns brown and where it is eaten. Color research tests broad words like brown, not toffee, so the claims here are about the sweet itself.

Cooked hotter than caramels

Candy science

Candy makers name sugar stages after what a drop of syrup does in cold water. Caramels stop at the firm-ball stage, 245–250 °F, and butterscotch at soft crack, 270–290 °F. Toffee goes on to hard crack, 300–310 °F, when the syrup is about 99% sugar and a drop sets into brittle threads in cold water. A large amount of butter keeps sugar crystals from forming, which gives toffee its smooth, glassy break.1, 2

Milk browns it, not just sugar

Food science

Food scientists set caramel, fudge and toffee apart from other sugar sweets by their milk ingredients, which bring their colors, flavors and aromas. The authors of a 2019 toffee study put its browning down to Maillard and Strecker reactions between milk proteins and sugars, sped up by the 100–150 °C of cooking. Maillard browning needs amino acids; caramelization is sugar breaking down on its own.3, 4, 5

A Bonfire Night treat

Tradition

Bonfire toffee, or treacle toffee, is a hard, brittle toffee eaten in Britain at Halloween and on Guy Fawkes Night, often with toffee apples. Black treacle makes it so dark that cheaper versions add brown or black food coloring when there isn’t enough treacle to do the job.6, 7

Darker sweets up north, maybe

Handbook claim

Wikipedia, citing a food color handbook (Hutchings, 1999), says bonfire toffee is eaten mostly in the north of the UK, where darker sweets are preferred. That is one book’s remark, not a survey, and it could not be checked against the page itself.6

A football nickname

Folklore

Everton, the Liverpool club, are known as the Toffees, though they play in royal blue. The best-known story points to Mother Noblett’s, a toffee shop in Everton village; another to Ye Anciente Everton Toffee House, near the hotel where the club’s early meetings were held. Before games, a Toffee Lady still throws mints into the crowd.8

Sources (8)
  1. Exploratorium, “Science of Cooking: Candy-making Stages”.
  2. Exploratorium, “Science of Candy: What is Sugar?”.
  3. Hartel, R. W., von Elbe, J. H. & Hofberger, R. (2018). “Caramel, Fudge and Toffee”. In Confectionery Science and Technology, pp. 273–299. Springer. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-61742-8_10
  4. Bahrasemani Koohestani, M., Sahari, M. A. & Barzegar, M. (2019). The effect of jujube powder incorporation on the chemical, rheological, and sensory properties of toffee. Food Science & Nutrition, 7(2), 678–688. doi:10.1002/fsn3.912
  5. Wikipedia, “Maillard reaction”.
  6. Wikipedia, “Bonfire toffee”, citing Mason, L. (2004), Food Culture in Great Britain, p. 187, and Hutchings, J. B. (1999), Food Color and Appearance, p. 6.
  7. Wikipedia, “Candy apple”.
  8. Wikipedia, “Everton F.C.”, section on nicknames.

History

Toffee is a northern English sweet that took its modern form in the 1890s. As a color it is much newer: no color dictionary lists it, and its code turns up only in modern online lists.

  1. 1817

    First record of “taffy”, the dialect word that toffee is a variant of, according to the Oxford English Dictionary.1

  2. 1825

    First known use of “toffee” in print, for a candy made by boiling sugar and butter together.1, 2

  3. 1890

    In Halifax, Yorkshire, Violet and John Mackintosh buy a pastry shop and sell Mackintosh’s Celebrated Toffee, Violet’s blend of brittle English butterscotch and soft American caramel. Its success, says the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, changed what toffee meant: before, the word could describe almost any sugar or boiled sweet.3

  4. 1890s

    Toffee apples appear in English print. In an 1897 magazine story, a child is “sucking a toffee-apple”.4 After Everton move to Goodison Park in 1892, the club picks up the nickname the Toffees.5

  5. 1930

    Maerz and Paul’s A Dictionary of Color has butterscotch and taffy but no toffee. In 1955 the ISCC-NBS dictionary files their butterscotch as moderate brown, the group whose center is #6F4E37, almost the same as today’s toffee code, and their taffy as a light yellowish brown.6

  6. 2017

    The first release of the open-source color-name-list, a merge of many color lists, gives toffee as #755139. It is the earliest source found for the code.7

  7. 2019

    A study of toffee made with jujube powder measures a plain milk toffee at L* 62.9, about #C58D4F, a golden tan much lighter than the code.8

Sources (8)
  1. Wikipedia, “Toffee”, section Etymology, citing the Oxford English Dictionary, 2nd ed. (1989), “toffee” and “taffy”.
  2. Merriam-Webster, “toffee”, definition, etymology and first known use.
  3. Wikipedia, “Mackintosh’s”, citing Fitzgerald, R. (2004), “Mackintosh, John (1868–1920)”, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.
  4. Hughes, G. “Toffee Apples”. The Foods of England, quoting The Ludgate Monthly, 1897.
  5. Wikipedia, “Everton F.C.”, section on nicknames.
  6. Jaffer, A. “(M) Dictionary of Color”, the ISCC-NBS placements of Maerz and Paul’s color names (1955 dictionary).
  7. meodai/color-names, published as color-name-list, version 1.0.0 (23 April 2017), MIT license.
  8. Bahrasemani Koohestani, M., Sahari, M. A. & Barzegar, M. (2019). The effect of jujube powder incorporation on the chemical, rheological, and sensory properties of toffee. Food Science & Nutrition, 7(2), 678–688. doi:10.1002/fsn3.912, Table 3.

Questions

What color is toffee?

A warm, medium-dark brown with a reddish cast. The code used here is #755139 (RGB 117, 81, 57).

What is the difference between toffee and caramel?

As colors, toffee (#755139) is darker and redder, and caramel (#C68E17) is a lighter golden brown. As sweets, caramels are made with milk or cream and cooked to the firm-ball stage, 245–250 °F, so they stay chewy. Toffee is sugar and butter cooked to hard crack, 300–310 °F, so it sets hard and snaps.

Is toffee the same color as coffee?

Nearly. Coffee (#6F4E37) is a touch darker and grayer, and side by side most people would struggle to tell them apart.

Why is toffee brown?

Two kinds of browning happen in the pan. Sugar breaks down as it heats, and the milk proteins in butter react with sugars, the same Maillard browning that colors bread crust. The longer and hotter it cooks, the darker it gets.

What is the difference between toffee and butterscotch?

Butterscotch is cooked only to the soft-crack stage, 270–290 °F, and toffee to hard crack. The usual butterscotch code, #E09540, is a much lighter orange brown, though Maerz and Paul’s 1930 butterscotch sample sits close to the toffee code.

Is there an official toffee color code?

No. #755139 is the code color lists use, and the earliest source found for it is an open-source list of color names from 2017. No color dictionary or standard defines toffee.

Why are Everton called the Toffees?

The best-known story points to Mother Noblett’s, a toffee shop in Everton village; another to a toffee house near the hotel where the club’s early meetings took place. The team’s colors are royal blue and white, not toffee brown.

What colors go with toffee?

Cream and caramel gold for a cozy look, apple red for a festive one, teal for contrast, and ember orange with near-black for Bonfire Night.