Indian yellow

A warm orange yellow named after a glowing Indian pigment whose source was argued over for more than a century.

Overview

Indian yellow is a warm, moderate orange yellow. Its code, #E3A857, has strong red, about two-thirds green and a little blue, which softens it. It sits right beside honey and is a shade calmer than gamboge, the other old Asian yellow it is most often mixed up with.

The name comes from a pigment, known in India as piuri and in English as purree. It reached European color sellers as hard balls, dark brown outside and deep orange inside, with a strong smell. Chemically it is mostly the calcium and magnesium salts of euxanthic acid. Painters in Rajput and Mughal India used it on paper and even on palace walls, and European watercolorists took it up in the 1800s.

Where it came from was argued over for more than a century. In 1883 T. N. Mukharji wrote that milkmen near Monghyr, in Bihar, made it from the urine of cows fed only on mango leaves. Later writers, among them the author Victoria Finlay, found little else to back the story up. Then in 2016 researchers recovered the samples Mukharji had sent to Kew Gardens and found a chemical marker of cattle urine in some of them.

The web code is the color dictionary’s sample, not the pigment at its brightest. The real thing is transparent and glows: on an 18th-century Mewar painting where the museum identified Indian yellow, the ground samples near #F9BC48. On screens #E3A857 is a light color, so use black or dark brown text (10:1); white text reaches only 2.1:1. It pairs well with deep red, indigo and leaf green.

HEX#E3A857
RGBrgb(227, 168, 87)
HSLhsl(35, 71%, 62%)
HSV35°, 62%, 89%
CMYK0, 26, 62, 11
OKLCHoklch(77.1% 0.120 73.0)
Every code converts from the HEX value #E3A857. #E3A857 is the center of the ISCC-NBS category moderate orange yellow, where the 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary files Maerz and Paul’s 1930 samples of Indian yellow and purree (Jaffer’s table); it also gives strong orange yellow, #EAA221. Merriam-Webster agrees, defining the color as “a moderate to strong orange yellow.” CMYK is a screen-based estimate; print results vary.
Indian yellow color card, hex #E3A857: “A glowing mystery”

Indian yellow on the color map

The dictionary’s strong orange yellow sits just to the right of the web code, toward yellow, at about the same lightness but much purer. The horticultural chart’s value and the painted ground sit above and to the right: lighter, yellower and more intense, near the top edge. The outline is an approximate range, not a measured one.

Shades and tints

Tints with white

Shades with black

Tones with gray

Indian yellow sits in the middle. Tints add white, shades add black and tones add gray, in 10% steps out from it. Tap any swatch to copy its code.

Light and dark indian yellow

#F4DCBC
Pale Indian yellowMixed 60% with white. A warm cream.
#EECB9A
Light Indian yellowMixed 40% with white. A soft apricot buff.
#E3A857
Indian yellowThe reference color.
#EAA221
Strong orange yellowThe other ISCC-NBS category for Maerz and Paul’s Indian yellow. The same code as marigold. See marigold
#9F763D
Dark Indian yellowMixed 30% with black. An old-gold brown.
#72542C
Deep Indian yellowMixed 50% with black. A dark tobacco brown.

Colors that go with indian yellow

Pairings that work in rooms, outfits and interfaces.

Rajput page

Yellow ground, red robes and leaf green, as on painted pages from Rajasthan.

Indian yellow and indigo

Warm yellow on deep blue. Strong and calm at once.

Mango grove

Yellow with two leaf greens. Fresh and natural, good for food and gardens.

Evening watercolor

Soft glazes of yellow, coral and dusky violet.

Spice market

Yellow, chili red and turmeric orange on a dark brown. Rich and warm.

Indian yellow and slate

A modern pairing for buttons and highlights on a cool gray.

Color-wheel palettes

Pick a palette to see where its colors sit on the color wheel. The caret marks indian yellow. Tap a band to copy its code.

Similar colors

Sandy brown84%Fawn87%Indian yellowGamboge78%Marigold83%Honey86%Goldenrod79%

Lined up by hue around indian yellow. Hover a color to see how similar it is.The bar under each name shows how similar it is. Similarity comes from the distance between the two colors in OKLab, a model of how we see color.

Indian yellow vs gamboge

Indian yellow#E3A857 · hue 35°
  • Softer and a little more orange
  • Named for a pigment sold as balls of purree
  • Said to come from cows fed mango leaves
Gamboge#E49B0F · hue 39°
  • Purer and more intense, with almost no blue
  • Named for a tree resin from Cambodia
  • Fades in light and is a strong purgative

Meaning

  • Indian painting
  • Mango leaves
  • Disputed source
  • Tested at Kew

Indian yellow is a color with a mystery attached. For most of its history Europeans bought it without knowing what it was made of, and the one eyewitness account, from 1883, was doubted for a long time. Laboratory work since 2016 has made that account much more believable. The claims below rest on dictionaries, old reports and conservation science. No study has tested how the color Indian yellow makes people feel.

Sold as balls called purree

Word history

Merriam-Webster traces purree to Hindi piūṛī, akin to Sanskrit pīta, yellow. In 1844 the chemist John Stenhouse described the purree arriving in Britain from India and China as balls of three to four ounces, dark brown outside, deep orange inside, with a very peculiar smell.1, 2

One witness, mango-fed cows

Eyewitness account

In 1883 T. N. Mukharji, answering a question from Sir Joseph Hooker at Kew, wrote that a few milkmen at Mirzapur, near Monghyr, fed cows only on mango leaves and water, boiled down their urine and dried the sediment into balls. He said he saw it done, and that the cows “looked very unhealthy.” For a long time his letter was the only printed eyewitness account.3, 4

Long doubted

Historical record

Stenhouse thought purree came from a plant, not an animal, and an 1839 painting manual blamed the leaves of a shrub. In her 2002 book on color, Victoria Finlay found no one in Mirzapur who remembered the trade, and no record of the ban said to have ended it.2, 4

Kew samples point to urine

Laboratory analysis

Most of the materials Mukharji sent to Kew were found again in 2016. Their analysis, published in 2019, found the known ingredients of Indian yellow and, in some samples, hippuric acid, a substance found in the urine of cattle and other ruminants. The authors call it the first substantial link between animal urine and the pigment. It cannot show how the cows were fed or treated.5

It glows under ultraviolet light

Conservation science

Indian yellow fluoresces strongly. Cleveland Museum of Art conservators identified it on an 18th-century Mewar painting by its bright glow under ultraviolet light, and luminescence imaging first revealed it across the 1620s wall paintings of a palace in Bundi, Rajasthan.6, 7

Sources (7)
  1. Merriam-Webster, “Indian yellow” and “purree”, definitions and etymology.
  2. Stenhouse, “Examination of a yellow substance from India called Purree, from which the pigment called Indian Yellow is manufactured,” London and Edinburgh Philosophical Magazine 25 (November 1844), pp. 321–325.
  3. Mukharji, “Piuri or ‘Indian yellow,’” letter dated 27 August 1883, Journal of the Society of Arts 32 (23 November 1883).
  4. Wikipedia, “Indian yellow”, citing Taylor’s 1839 translation of Mérimée’s The Art of Painting in Oil and in Fresco, Finlay, Colour: Travels Through the Paintbox (2002), and St. Clair, The Secret Lives of Colour (2016).
  5. Ploeger, Shugar, Smith & Chen, “Late 19th century accounts of Indian yellow: The analysis of samples from the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew,” Dyes and Pigments 160 (2019), pp. 418–431.
  6. Cleveland Museum of Art, “Friends of Krishna, folio 163 from a Bhakti Ratnavali of Vishnu Puri” (1970.510), collection record.
  7. Tamburini et al., “New insights into the composition of Indian yellow and its use in a Rajasthani wall painting,” Microchemical Journal 137 (2018), pp. 238–249.

History

Indian yellow’s story runs from Rajput palaces to London color sellers, and from a single letter in 1883 to a laboratory study of the samples that came with it.

  1. 1620–30

    Painters at the Badal Mahal in the Garh Palace, Bundi, in Rajasthan, use Indian yellow widely in their wall paintings. Before this find, the pigment was known only from paintings on paper.1

  2. 1725–50

    A Mewar painter covers the whole background of a page from a Bhakti Ratnavali with Indian yellow. The page is now in Cleveland.2

  3. 1839

    An English translation of Léonor Mérimée’s painting manual says the color comes from the leaves of a shrub, Memecylon tinctorium, and guesses from its smell that cow’s urine is used to extract it.3

  4. 1844

    John Stenhouse analyzes purree imported into Britain from India and China. He notes the belief that it comes from animal gallstones or urine, but concludes it is a plant product.4

  5. 1883

    T. N. Mukharji’s letter of 27 August describes piuri made at Monghyr from the urine of cows fed on mango leaves. He sends Hooker samples of the pigment, the urine, a collecting pot and mango leaves.5

  6. 1889

    Van Gogh paints The Starry Night. A 2008 imaging study suggests Indian yellow, with zinc yellow, in the deeper yellow of the moon and stars.6

  7. Early 1900s

    Production ends. Pigment handbooks say it was banned around 1908 and no longer sold by about 1921, but no record of such a law has been found.3, 7

  8. 2002

    Victoria Finlay goes looking for the trade in Mirzapur for her book Colour, finds no one who remembers it, and comes away skeptical.3

  9. 2016–2019

    Mukharji’s samples are found again at Kew. Analysis of them, published in 2019, detects hippuric acid, a marker of ruminant urine.8

Sources (8)
  1. Tamburini et al., “New insights into the composition of Indian yellow and its use in a Rajasthani wall painting,” Microchemical Journal 137 (2018), pp. 238–249.
  2. Cleveland Museum of Art, “Friends of Krishna, folio 163 from a Bhakti Ratnavali of Vishnu Puri” (1970.510), collection record.
  3. Wikipedia, “Indian yellow”, quoting Taylor’s 1839 translation of Mérimée and citing Baer et al., “Indian Yellow,” in Artists’ Pigments, vol. 1 (1986), Finlay (2002) and St. Clair (2016).
  4. Stenhouse, “Examination of a yellow substance from India called Purree, from which the pigment called Indian Yellow is manufactured,” London and Edinburgh Philosophical Magazine 25 (November 1844), pp. 321–325.
  5. Mukharji, “Piuri or ‘Indian yellow,’” letter dated 27 August 1883, Journal of the Society of Arts 32 (23 November 1883).
  6. ColourLex, “Indian Yellow”, citing Zhao, Berns, Taplin & Coddington, “An Investigation of Multispectral Imaging for the Mapping of Pigments in Paintings,” Proc. SPIE 6810 (2008).
  7. Bailkin, “Indian Yellow: Making and Breaking the Imperial Palette,” Journal of Material Culture 10, 2 (2005), pp. 197–214.
  8. Ploeger, Shugar, Smith & Chen, “Late 19th century accounts of Indian yellow: The analysis of samples from the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew,” Dyes and Pigments 160 (2019), pp. 418–431.

Indian yellow in use

Indian painting on a bright yellow ground with a red border: a blue-skinned Krishna sits with three friends before a white-bearded elder, stands below beside three white and spotted cows, and two men talk near trees and a small pavilion
#F9BC48#C65B3E#747236#C87E83
PaintingFriends of Krishna, from a Bhakti Ratnavali (1725–50)

A page from Mewar, in Rajasthan, now at the Cleveland Museum of Art. Krishna sits with his friends before his foster father Nanda, and below he greets three cows. The museum says the entire background is Indian yellow, identified by its bright fluorescence under ultraviolet light. The ground samples near #F9BC48, lighter and purer than the web code.

#F9BC48#C65B3E#747236#C87E83
Source: Cleveland Museum of Art

Palettes are sampled in-house.

Questions

What color is Indian yellow?

A warm, moderate orange yellow. Its code is #E3A857 (RGB 227, 168, 87), the 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary’s value for Maerz and Paul’s Indian yellow sample. The pigment itself is brighter and glows in sunlight.

Was Indian yellow really made from cow urine?

Probably. The only eyewitness account, from T. N. Mukharji in 1883, says it was made from the urine of cows fed on mango leaves. It was doubted for decades, but in 2019 researchers found hippuric acid, a marker of cattle urine, in samples he had sent to Kew.

What is purree?

Purree, or piuri, is the raw pigment: hard balls, dark brown outside and deep orange inside, which color makers washed and purified into Indian yellow. Merriam-Webster also uses purree as a name for the color.

Why did Indian yellow disappear?

Production stopped in the early 1900s. Handbooks say it was banned around 1908 and gone from the market by about 1921, often linked to the treatment of the cows, but no record of a law has been found.

Is Indian yellow the same as gamboge?

No. Gamboge is a resin from Cambodian trees and its usual code, #E49B0F, is purer and more intense. Indian yellow came from India in balls of purree and its code is softer. Both were used in Indian painting.

What is Indian yellow paint made of today?

Paints sold as Indian yellow today are mixtures of modern synthetic pigments chosen to imitate the old color. The original pigment is no longer made.

What colors go with Indian yellow?

Deep red, indigo and leaf green, as on Rajput paintings. For a modern look, try slate gray or a dark chocolate brown.