What colors make yellow?

No two paints. But on every screen, red and green light.

Overview

In paint, nothing makes yellow. It is a primary color for painters and for printers alike, so it has to come from a tube or an ink.1

With light the answer is different, and a little surprising: red and green light together make yellow.1 Every yellow on a phone, television or computer screen is made this way, from two lights that are not yellow at all.

What you can mix in paint is a different yellow from the one you have: paler, warmer, greener, or duller, as in mustard and gold.

Red light
Green light
Yellow#FFFF00
In paintA primary: it can’t be mixed
In printA primary: one of the three inks
On a screenRed light + green light
PalerAdd white
WarmerAdd a touch of red or orange
DullerAdd a touch of purple or brown

Red and green light make yellow

Equal red and green: yellow

Red lightfull strength
Green lightfull strength
Yellow#FFFF00

Less green: orange

Red lightfull strength
Green lightat 50%
Orange#FF8000

Less red: yellow-green

Red lightat 50%
Green lightfull strength
Chartreuse#80FF00

A screen has only three lights in each pixel: red, green and blue. To show yellow it turns the red and the green full on and leaves the blue off, as in #FFFF00.1, 2

It works because of the eye, not because of the light. The eye has three kinds of color receptors, the cones, which respond most to long, medium and short wavelengths.2 A single yellow light stirs the first two kinds together. Red light and green light, arriving at once, stir the same two, and the eye has no way to tell the mixture from the real thing.

Why no two paints make yellow

Red and green paint make brown

Green
Brown#724240

The mix that makes yellow in light makes brown in paint.

Orange and green paint make olive

Orange
Green
Olive#74983D

Both contain yellow, but the red and blue they bring along dull it.

Paint swatches are worked out with a pigment model, not measured from real paint. Real tubes differ from brand to brand.

Lights add up: each one you switch on makes the result brighter. Paints work the other way. Each paint absorbs part of the light that falls on it, so a mixture is always darker than its brightest part.3 Yellow is the lightest color on the wheel, and nothing darker can be mixed up to it.

For the same reason yellow is a starting point in printing. Yellow is one of the three inks, with cyan and magenta, and the other two cannot produce it.1 Orange and green both contain yellow, but mixing them only adds red and blue to it.

How to mix mustard, gold, cream and other yellows

Pale yellow

Whitetitanium white, mostly
Pale yellow#F0F8A9

Golden yellow

Yellowcadmium yellow, mostly
Redcadmium red, a touch
Golden yellow#FFCD22

Mustard

Brownumber, a touch
Mustard#D6A826

Greenish lemon

Yellowcadmium yellow, mostly
Bluecerulean, a touch
Lemon-lime#E4F60E
To getAdd to your yellowNamed yellows of that kind
Pale yellowWhiteCream, pale yellow, butter yellow
Golden yellowA touch of red or orangeGolden yellow, saffron, amber
MustardA touch of purple, yellow’s opposite, or brownMustard yellow, goldenrod, ochre
Greenish yellowA touch of blue or greenLemon, chartreuse, green yellow
Soft, earthy yellowWhite and a touch of brownStraw, flax, Naples yellow

Yellow is easily overpowered. Add the second color in the smallest amounts you can manage, on the tip of the brush, and stir before adding more. A yellow that has gone too far toward green or brown is hard to bring back, and it is usually quicker to start again.

No mixture makes yellow brighter. White makes it paler, not stronger, so the only way to a more vivid yellow is a more vivid paint.

Yellow in print

Yellow and magenta make red

Yellow
Magenta
Red#FF0000

Yellow and cyan make green

Yellow
Cyan
Green#00FF00

Ink swatches use ideal inks. Real inks are less pure, so real overprints are darker and duller.

Color printing uses yellow as one of its three colored inks, beside cyan and magenta.1 Yellow ink absorbs blue light and reflects red and green, which is the same pair of lights a screen uses to show it. Printed over magenta it leaves red; printed over cyan it leaves green.4

Yellows to aim for

For the whole family, see shades of yellow.

Questions

What two colors make yellow?

Red and green light, as on a screen. In paint and ink no two colors make yellow, because it is a primary color there.

Can you mix yellow paint from other colors?

No. Any paint you mix is darker than its lightest part, and yellow is the lightest color on the wheel. You have to start with a yellow.

Why do red and green make yellow in light but brown in paint?

Lights add together, and red and green light stir the same receptors in the eye that yellow light does. Paints take light away, so red and green paint together absorb most of it and leave a dark brown.

How do you make mustard yellow?

Add a very small amount of purple or brown to yellow. An earth yellow such as ochre gets you there faster.

How do you make golden yellow?

Add a touch of red or orange to yellow. A little brown on top of that turns it toward old gold.

How do you make pale yellow or cream?

Add white to yellow. For cream, use mostly white with a little yellow and the smallest touch of brown.

How do you make yellow brighter?

You can’t by mixing. Every paint you add dulls or pales it, so use the most vivid yellow you have on its own.

Do orange and green make yellow?

No. Both contain yellow, but together they also bring red and blue, and the result is an olive or a yellowish brown.

Keep reading

Sources (4)
  1. Wikipedia, “Yellow”: yellow is a primary color in the subtractive systems used in painting and color printing, and in the RGB color model a secondary color made by combining red and green light at equal intensity.
  2. Wikipedia, “RGB color model”: equal red and green light make yellow, green and blue make cyan, blue and red make magenta, and all three make white; the eye’s three kinds of cone cells respond most to long, medium and short wavelengths.
  3. Wikipedia, “Color mixing”, on additive and subtractive mixing, citing David Briggs’s The Dimensions of Colour.
  4. Wikipedia, “CMYK color model”: pairs of cyan, magenta and yellow ink produce red, green and blue, and all three together an imperfect black.