What colors make black?

All three primaries, or any dark color and its opposite, pushed until almost no light comes back.

Overview

Red, yellow and blue make black, or something very close to it. Mixed in the right amounts, the three primary colors of paint absorb nearly all the light that falls on them, and what little comes back looks black.1

Two paints can do it as well, if they are dark and sit opposite each other on the color wheel: a deep blue with a brown, or a deep red with a dark green. Each pair holds all three primaries between them.2

Printers have a black ink because their three colors together only reach a dark, muddy brown.3 On a screen black is not mixed at all. It is what you see when the lights are off.1

Dark greenphthalo green
Near black#313230
Three colorsRed + yellow + blue
Two colorsBlue + brown, or red + green
CoolerMore blue
WarmerMore red or brown
In printBlack ink, often over other inks
On a screenNo light at all: #000000

Red, yellow and blue make black

Mostly blue, some red, a little yellow

Yellowcadmium yellow, a little
Bluecobalt blue, mostly
Near black#3C3A44

Equal parts give brown, not black

Brown#774936

Paint swatches are worked out with a pigment model, not measured from real paint. Real tubes differ from brand to brand. The model’s darkest mixes stop at a deep charcoal; real paints, used thickly, go darker.

  1. Start with blue and red

    Mix a dark purple, with more blue than red. These are the two darkest primaries, so they do most of the work.

  2. Add yellow a little at a time

    Yellow is purple’s opposite. Each touch takes away some of the purple until the mix has no clear color left.

  3. Correct the lean

    Looks brown? Add blue. Looks green? Add red. Looks purple? Add yellow. Test it by spreading a little thinly or mixing a bit with white, which shows the hidden color.

The same three paints in equal amounts make brown. Black needs the balance tipped toward blue, the darkest of the three, with only enough yellow to cancel the purple.

Two colors that make black

Deep red and dark green

Dark greenphthalo green
Near black#313230

Two dark, strong paints that are opposites. The mix is close to neutral.

Deep blue and brown

Deep blueultramarine
Reddish brownsienna
Blue-black#2A323F

A cool black. More brown warms it; equal amounts give a soft, neutral dark.

Three dark paints

Dark greenphthalo green
Deep blueultramarine
Near black#2A2D32

A little deep blue cools the red and green mix and darkens it further.

These pairs are complementary colors: opposites on the wheel. Mixed, they cancel each other’s color and leave a dark neutral.2 Any mixture of paints is darker and duller than its parts, so the darker the two paints you start from, the closer the result comes to black.4

Light, bright paints will not get there. Yellow and purple are opposites too, but yellow is so light that the mix stops at brown.

Mixed black and black from a tube

Lamp black#1F1F1Fsoot

Black paints are among the oldest there are. Charcoal drew the black lines of cave art; lamp black is soot, and ivory black was made by charring bone.1 A black from the tube is darker and more even than anything mixed.

A mixed black always leans a little toward one of its parts, which can be an advantage: a bluish black for a night sky, a brownish one for hair or shadow. Painters have long argued over which is better. Renoir said he had tried to replace black with a mixture of red and blue, and with cobalt blue or ultramarine, but always came back to ivory black, which he called the queen of colors.1

Warm black, cool black, soft black

To getAdd to your blackNamed blacks and near-blacks
Cool, bluish blackBlueObsidian, Payne’s gray, midnight blue
Warm, brownish blackBrown or redEbony, wenge, oxblood
Soft blackA touch of whiteCharcoal, onyx, graphite
Deepest blackNothing: use a black pigmentJet black, lamp black, Vantablack

White turns black into gray straight away, and shows which way the black leans: a mixed black with too much blue gives a blue-gray, one with too much red a mauve-gray. That makes a dab of white the quickest test of a mixed black.

Black in print

Cyan, magenta and yellow, in theory

Cyan
Magenta
Yellow
Black#000000

With ideal inks the three absorb all light. Real inks give a dark, muddy brown instead.

In theory a printer’s three colored inks make black when all three overlap. In practice the inks are not pure enough, and the overlap comes out as an imperfect, brownish black. That is why four-color printing adds a fourth ink: the K in CMYK is black.3

For large dark areas printers go one step further and print black over the colors. This is called rich black: a typical mixture is full black with half-strength cyan, magenta and yellow under it, which absorbs more light than black ink alone.5

Black on a screen

Black is the color seen when no visible light reaches the eye.1 A screen makes it by leaving a pixel’s red, green and blue lights switched off, which is the code #000000.

No mixture of lights can make black, because every light added makes the result brighter. Mixing all the lights gives white, the opposite of what mixing all the paints gives. See the color mixing chart for the two side by side.

Questions

What two colors make black?

A deep blue and a brown, or a deep red and a dark green. Each pair is a color and its opposite, so together they absorb almost all light.

What three colors make black?

Red, yellow and blue. Use mostly blue, less red and only a little yellow; equal amounts give brown.

How do you make black without black paint?

Mix the darkest blue you have with a dark brown, and adjust: more blue if it looks brown, more brown if it looks blue.

Why does my mixed black look brown, purple or green?

One primary is missing or too weak. Brown needs more blue, purple needs more yellow, and green needs more red.

Does mixing all the colors make black?

With paint it makes a dark brown or a near-black, depending on the amounts. With light it makes white.

What colors make black icing or food coloring?

Red, blue and yellow food coloring together, or red, blue and green. Starting from chocolate icing takes far less coloring than starting from white.

Is black a color?

In light, black is the absence of color: no light, no color. In paint it is a color like any other, sold as a pigment and mixed like one.

Keep reading

Sources (5)
  1. Wikipedia, “Black”: black is the color seen when no visible light reaches the eye; three primary pigments mixed in the right proportions reflect so little light that the result is called black. Also on lamp black, ivory black and Renoir’s remark about mixing black.
  2. Wikipedia, “Complementary colors”, on the complementary pairs of the traditional, RGB and CMY color models.
  3. Wikipedia, “CMYK color model”: pairs of cyan, magenta and yellow ink produce red, green and blue, and all three together an imperfect black.
  4. Wikipedia, “Color theory”: a mixture of pigments is always darker and less saturated than its parts, which moves it toward gray or near-black; lightness is adjusted with white, black or a color’s complement.
  5. Wikipedia, “Rich black”, citing The Guild Handbook of Scientific Illustration (2003) and Johansson, Lundberg and Ryberg’s A Guide to Graphic Print Production (2012).