Payne's gray

A dark blue-gray named after a watercolor teacher’s favorite mix.

Overview

Payne’s gray is a dark gray with a clear blue cast, shown on screen as #536878. It is named after William Payne (1760–1830), an English watercolor painter who became the most fashionable drawing master in London in the 1790s.

Unlike most pigment colors, Payne’s gray was never one pigment. It is a ready-made mix of a blue with browns, reds or black, sold so painters didn’t have to mix their own. The recipe has changed many times. One 1890s account lists indigo, raw sienna and lake. Today’s versions are usually a blue mixed with black.

Payne used his gray for the middle distance of his landscapes, the hills and trees that sit between the dark foreground and the blue sky. At full strength it is very dark; thinned with water it gives a soft, misty blue-gray.

As a design color, #536878 is a quiet, slightly moody blue-gray. White text on it is easy to read, and it pairs well with warm paper whites, ochre, blush and coral.

HEX#536878
RGBrgb(83, 104, 120)
HSLhsl(206, 18%, 40%)
HSV206°, 31%, 47%
CMYK31, 13, 0, 53
OKLCHoklch(50.6% 0.036 241.2)
Every code converts from the HEX value #536878. #536878 is the center of ISCC-NBS color group 186, grayish blue, in John Foster’s sRGB version. The 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary places Payne’s gray from Maerz and Paul’s A Dictionary of Color (1930) in that group and in group 187, dark grayish blue (Jaffer’s table), and Wikipedia uses the same code. CMYK is a screen-based estimate; print results vary.
Payne's gray color card, hex #536878: “No Payne, no gain”

Payne's gray on the color map

The dark grayish blue sits just below the outline, darker but with the same hue. The thin wash sits above it, lighter but the same hue. The shadowed trees in Payne’s drawing sit well outside, much warmer: after two centuries the paper has yellowed, and the museum does not say which grays he used, so read this dot as a reminder that old watercolor grays rarely look like the web code, not as a measure of the paint. The outline is an approximate range, not a measured one.

Shades and tints

Tints with white

Shades with black

Tones with gray

Payne's gray sits in the middle. Tints add white, shades add black and tones add gray, in 10% steps out from it. Tap any swatch to copy its code.

Light and dark payne's gray

#E5E8EB
Payne’s gray washMixed 85% with white. The palest wash, almost white with a cool tint.
#98A4AE
Light Payne’s grayMixed 40% with white. A soft, misty blue-gray.
#536878
Payne’s grayThe reference color.
#3A4954
Dark Payne’s grayMixed 30% with black. Close to the paint at full strength.
#36454F
Dark grayish blueThe other ISCC-NBS group for Maerz and Paul’s Payne’s gray. It has its own page as charcoal. See charcoal

Colors that go with payne's gray

Pairings that work in rooms, outfits and interfaces.

Payne’s gray on paper

Blue-gray washes on warm watercolor paper. Soft and painterly.

Middle distance

Layered grays from pale to dark, like hills fading into haze.

Payne’s gray and ochre

Blue-gray with a warm earth yellow, like the old recipe’s ingredients. Grounded and calm.

Payne’s gray and blush

Cool gray softened with pale pink. Good for weddings and stationery.

Payne’s gray and sage

Two muted, natural tones. Quiet and restful.

Payne’s gray and coral

A warm orange-pink against the cool gray. Lively but not loud.

Color-wheel palettes

Pick a palette to see where its colors sit on the color wheel. The caret marks payne's gray. Tap a band to copy its code.

Similar colors

Ebony69%Feldgrau69%Hooker's green69%Payne's grayDim gray81%Dove gray78%Wenge64%

Lined up by hue around payne's gray. Hover a color to see how similar it is.The bar under each name shows how similar it is. Similarity comes from the distance between the two colors in OKLab, a model of how we see color.

Payne’s gray vs charcoal

Payne’s gray#536878 · hue 206°
  • Named after a watercolor painter’s paint mix
  • A mid-dark blue-gray, about 40% lightness
  • ISCC-NBS grayish blue
Charcoal#36454F · hue 204°
  • Named after burned wood used for drawing
  • Darker, about 26% lightness
  • ISCC-NBS dark grayish blue, the other group for Payne’s gray

Meaning

  • Drawing lessons
  • Distance and haze
  • Watercolor
  • A ready-made mix

Payne’s gray stands for the watercolor painter’s craft: a teacher’s shortcut for painting distance and air, sold ready-mixed so that pupils could copy the effect. It means haze, rain and soft shadow more than gloom. Color research tests basic words such as gray and blue, never Payne’s gray, so there is no evidence about its effect on mood.

A gray for the middle distance

Historical record

Payne used his gray for all the steps of his middle distance, painted the far distance and sky in blue, and kept Indian ink or lampblack for shadows in the foreground.1

A teacher’s shortcut

Historical record

Payne’s style was new and effective but easy to learn, and he became the most fashionable drawing master in London. In 1835 the color maker George Field listed Payne’s gray among ready-mixed grays for watercolor, alongside other masters’ tints sold in cakes “to facilitate the progress of their pupils”.2, 3

No fixed recipe

Historical record

Payne’s gray has always been a mix. Field in 1835 said such grays were made of sepia and indigo or other blues with madder or other lakes. The 1895 Dictionary of National Biography gives indigo, raw sienna and lake. Modern versions are usually a blue, such as ultramarine, mixed with black.3, 2, 4

Older mixtures fade

Secondhand source

A study of 19th-century painting manuals, as summarized on Wikipedia, says Payne’s gray has poor resistance to light: its faint violet tint fades, leaving a plain neutral gray. The report concerns older mixtures, such as those made with indigo. We have not read the original, so treat it as a secondhand report.4

Sources (4)
  1. Long, Basil S. (1922). William Payne, Water-Colour Painter, Working 1776–1830. London: Walker’s Galleries, pp. 11–12, quoting Richard and Samuel Redgrave.
  2. Monkhouse, W. C. (1895). “Payne, William (fl. 1800)”. Dictionary of National Biography, vol. 44.
  3. Field, George (1835). Chromatography; or, A Treatise on Colours and Pigments. London, p. 170, “Of Gray”.
  4. Wikipedia, “Payne’s grey”, citing N. Eastaugh et al., Pigment Compendium (2004), p. 293, and L. Carlyle, The Artist’s Assistant (2001), pp. 497–498.

History

Payne’s gray began as one teacher’s working method, outlived his fame by two centuries, and ended up in color dictionaries and on every watercolor chart.

  1. 1760

    William Payne is born, probably in Devon. He works in the engineers’ department of Plymouth Dockyard before turning to art.1, 2

  2. 1776

    Payne first exhibits, at the Incorporated Society of Artists in London. Sir Joshua Reynolds later praises his views of slate quarries near Plympton.1

  3. 1790

    Payne moves to London and settles in Thornhaugh Street, Bedford Square. His easy-to-learn “style” makes him the most fashionable drawing master in the city.1

  4. 1809–1812

    Payne is an associate of the Water-colour Society and shows seventeen drawings in its exhibitions. By the time he dies, in 1830, he is largely forgotten.1, 2

  5. 1835

    George Field’s Chromatography notes gray mixtures “sold under the name of Payne’s gray, neutral tint, &c.” for watercolor. It is the first recorded use of the name; Field says such grays were first used by a painter he spells Cousins, not Payne.3, 4

  6. 1895

    The Dictionary of National Biography calls a neutral tint of indigo, raw sienna and lake Payne’s best-known invention, and notes that a Payne’s gray is still sold by artists’ color makers.1

  7. 1912

    Robert Ridgway’s Color Standards and Color Nomenclature names a family of six Payne’s grays, from pale to deep, on its plate XLIX.5

  8. 1922

    Basil Long writes that every watercolor painter knows Payne’s gray, but few are aware it is named after a painter, in a short book on Payne’s drawings.2

  9. 1930–1955

    Maerz and Paul’s A Dictionary of Color prints Payne’s gray as a color sample. The 1955 ISCC-NBS dictionary files that sample as grayish blue and dark grayish blue; the center of grayish blue is today’s code, #536878.4, 6

Sources (6)
  1. Monkhouse, W. C. (1895). “Payne, William (fl. 1800)”. Dictionary of National Biography, vol. 44. Wikisource notes the dates 1760–1830 from the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.
  2. Long, Basil S. (1922). William Payne, Water-Colour Painter, Working 1776–1830. London: Walker’s Galleries.
  3. Field, George (1835). Chromatography; or, A Treatise on Colours and Pigments. London, p. 170.
  4. Wikipedia, “Payne’s grey”, citing Maerz and Paul, A Dictionary of Color (1930), p. 201 (first use, 1835) and plate 47, sample A9.
  5. Ridgway, Robert (1912). Color Standards and Color Nomenclature. Washington, DC: the author, plate XLIX.
  6. Jaffer, A. “Maerz and Paul color names” (ISCC-NBS placements), with ISCC-NBS centroids from Jaffer’s color dictionaries.

Payne's gray in use

A watercolor of a stone bridge with two arches over a river, a rider crossing it, large trees on the left and a misty gray cliff behind, set in a pale gray-green mount with the title handwritten below
#706355#8D806E#C9BCA3#E7E0CA
PaintingDenham Bridge upon the Tavy by William Payne (1780–1830)

A small Devon landscape in watercolor at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, signed “W. Payne”. It shows the method he taught: dark trees and banks in front, hazy gray hills behind the bridge, and a pale sky. The museum does not record which grays he used, and two centuries have warmed the paper, so the grays now photograph as soft warm browns, about #706355 in the shadows, far from the web code.

#706355#8D806E#C9BCA3#E7E0CA
Source: Metropolitan Museum of Art

Palettes are sampled in-house.

Questions

What color is Payne’s gray?

A dark gray with a blue cast. The usual code is #536878 (RGB 83, 104, 120). As paint it looks almost black at full strength and a soft blue-gray when thinned with water.

Who was Payne?

William Payne (1760–1830), an English watercolor painter from Devon who became a popular drawing teacher in London in the 1790s. He used a ready-mixed gray for the hazy middle distance of his landscapes, and the mix took his name.

What is Payne’s gray made of?

It has always been a mix, not a single pigment. Old recipes combine indigo or Prussian blue with an earth such as sienna or ochre and a red lake. Most modern versions are a blue, often ultramarine, mixed with black.

Is it spelled Payne’s gray or Payne’s grey?

Both. Grey is the British spelling and gray the American one. They name the same color.

What is the difference between Payne’s gray and charcoal?

They share a hue, but charcoal, #36454F, is much darker. Both codes come from the same color dictionary, which placed Payne’s gray across both groups.

What colors go with Payne’s gray?

Warm paper whites and cream for a soft, painterly look, ochre or mustard for warmth, and blush or coral for contrast. White text reads well on it.