Baker-Miller pink stands for one idea: that a color on the walls can calm angry people. Unusually, the research tested this exact paint, not just the word pink. The first reports were striking, but they came from the people who ran the cells, without comparison groups. Later, better-controlled tests mostly found no effect on strength, blood pressure or aggression, and one found a small drop in reported anxiety.
The first report had no control
Uncontrolled reportSchauss’s 1979 paper quoted a Navy memo: since the Seattle cell was painted pink, there had been “no incidents of erratic or hostile behavior” among new inmates, and 15 minutes in the cell was enough. There was no comparison cell, and the officers who chose the pink also judged the results.1, 2
The strength test did not hold up
Not replicatedSchauss based the idea on an arm push-down test: a subject looking at a pink card seemed to resist less. Follow-up studies found small strength effects in two tests and none in a third. In 1988, a study of 54 adults looking at pink or white panels found no difference in blood pressure, pulse or grip strength.1, 2, 3
A jail’s pink year
One field studyThe Santa Clara County jail in California repainted its strip search room from pale blue to hot pink in 1979. Fights fell in the first month, then rose, peaking in the last months of the pink year. Over the year there was little or no difference. The authors, Schauss among them, suggested that staff belief in the method may explain the early drop.2
Lower anxiety in one small study
One small studyIn 1987, 46 students sat for five minutes in a room painted Baker-Miller pink or red. The pink group reported lower anxiety, but their grip strength and steadiness of hand did not differ. The authors called this minimal support. The comparison was with red, not with a neutral color.4
No effect in a controlled prison trial
One controlled trialIn a 2015 study, 59 male prisoners in Switzerland, held in detention for breaking prison rules, were randomly placed in an all-pink cell or a white cell with a gray floor. Guards rated their aggression on arrival and after three days. Aggression fell in both cells, with no difference between them. The authors warned that a pink cell might humiliate inmates instead.5, 6
Pink cells are still in use
News reportDespite the results, some prisons in the United States, Switzerland, Germany, Poland, Austria and the United Kingdom have painted cells pink. In 2015 the BBC reported that 20% of prisons and police stations in Switzerland had at least one pink cell.7